Monarch Watch Blog

Monarch Population Status

Saturday, July 10th, 2010 at 1:24 pm by Chip Taylor
Filed under Monarch Population Status | 6 Comments »

If you have been following the news about monarch populations over the last 8 months, you know that the 2009 overwintering monarch population in Mexico covered a forest area of only 1.92 hectares. This figure represents an all time low for overwintering monarchs and is well below the long-term average of 7.44 hectares (1994-2010). We worried about these low numbers because of the possibility that a devastating storm could drive the population even lower. And then it happened…a storm of the worst possible dimensions hit the overwintering area starting on 2 February. Fifteen inches of rain fell over a four day period. Large hail hit some areas and snow and freezing temperatures were reported subsequently during another period of precipitation. The consequences were devastating for the residents of the monarch overwintering area. Accounts of the flooding and landslides can be found in the Mexico category of the Monarch Watch Blog.

Attempts to find out how the monarchs fared following these winter storms were unsatisfactory. No measurements were made of the numbers of monarchs killed by the storms. Accounts by visitors to the colonies after the storms suggested that substantial numbers of monarchs died during these events. Reports from reliable observers suggested that as much as 80% of the butterflies died at some colonies while others suggested moderate mortality at one large colony of perhaps 20%. Overall we estimated that at least 50% of the monarchs died during the winter months, recognizing that this value could have been low.

Our next concern was the number of butterflies coming north in late February and March. Would the number of surviving butterflies be sufficient to establish a first generation in Texas and the South large enough to lead to a recolonization of the northern breeding areas and a recovery of the population?

Fortunately, the conditions encountered by the monarchs that reached Texas were favorable. Rainfall over the previous 6 months signaled an end to the long drought and produced an abundance of milkweed. The fire ants were down due to the drought and temperatures were lower than normal which seems to favor production of first generation monarchs. The result, in spite of the low number of returning monarchs, was a substantial first generation. These butterflies colonized much of the northern breeding area from late April to mid-June; however, not all areas were well colonized.

The numbers of monarchs reaching the northeastern area (New England and New York) seemed to be well below average, leading to the expectation that the fall migration in this region will be low. Rainfall and temperatures in the central area (Ohio, Indiana, Tennessee, etc.) were not ideal as monarchs arrived from the south and the fall population in this region is likely to be below average except for those areas receiving butterflies from eastern Ontario, which reported many arriving monarchs in May and early June. Based on the numbers of arriving monarchs and the abundance of eggs and larvae found by observers, the fall migration in the east north central region (eastern Dakotas to Michigan) should be above average – assuming that temperatures do not reach the 100s before the end of August.

In summary, it appears that the monarchs are making a modest recovery and I expect the overwintering population will measure close to 3 hectares.

  1. 6 Responses to “Monarch Population Status”

  2. By Lisa Bowyer on Jul 31, 2010

    I live in Michigan – Northwest Lower Penisula and I have been following the population issues since January and was very concerned about their numbers as they start to migrate through here in July and August…I have been very pleasently surprised to find there are more butterflies, caterpillars and eggs than I have seen in years! We’ve had an excellent Milkweed crop this year, so they have loads of food. I’m hoping this is true for the general population….

  3. By Orpha Honzik on Aug 11, 2010

    Here in northcentral Wisconsin we have enjoyed a quite noticeably increased number of Monarchs this year. From my garden and our section of the roadway I have rescued in excess of 50 caterpillars whereas last year our total rescues for the entire summer was a pitiful 24.

  4. By Bonnie Novak on Aug 13, 2010

    As a former science teacher, I have made my flower garden into a reserve for Monarchs..planting many milkweed plants and flowers.
    This year, my numbers are very low…I have not had nearly as many as in years past.
    We all hope they recover next year.

    Bonnie Novak
    Akron, OH

  5. By Ilene Cook on Aug 21, 2010

    We live in the Poconos which is in northeast Pennsylvania. We plant milkweed and butterfly weed in our backyard. We saw very few monarch butterflies and caterpillars the last few years. This year the number of caterpillars in our yard is really encouraging. We haven’t seen this many caterpillars in probably 5 or 6 years. We had a very hot dry summer but we water by hand to maintain the plants. The wild milkweed in the area seems to be holding its own this year as well so hopefully we have higher numbers of monarchs ready to migrate south this year.

  6. By George Rohde on Oct 11, 2010

    On October 10, 2010 I observed 18-20 Monarchs migrating passed a farmstead in central North Dakota. The weather was 80 degrees, light wind, and clear sky. The area and most of the State have not suffered a killing frost. The temps have remained above normal. Usually, these late migrants would not have survived the normal killing frosts and inaddition would have been unable to find any flowers.

  7. By Betty on Nov 8, 2010

    I would like to konw, being new to the monarch migration, if they return to the same areas each year along thier route? I would like to go see this when it happens if I could
    but would like to have a general idea of where I might go. I’d like to see LOTS of them if possible. 🙂 Thanks.

Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.